Stents and bypass surgery didn’t help heart patients live longer, 13-year study finds

Doctor explaining heart stents to an older patient.(NaturalHealth365) For decades, heart patients have heard the same advice: open the narrowed artery before a heart attack strikes. As a result, heart stents and bypass surgery became the standard fix, even for many people who felt fine. Now, one of the longest heart studies ever completed has put that promise to the test.

The major new study, published in JAMA, tracked more than 5,000 patients for up to 13 years. After 11 years, 25.8 percent of patients given early procedures had died, compared with 26.9 percent who started with medication and lifestyle changes. In other words, the survival difference was too small to matter.

What the 13-year heart study actually found

The original trial, called ISCHEMIA, enrolled 5,179 people at 320 sites in 37 countries. Every patient had stable coronary artery disease and at least moderate ischemia. In plain terms, a stress test showed reduced blood flow to the heart.

Many people first discover trouble through heart scans or an abnormal stress test. After that, the pressure to act fast can feel intense.

Half of the patients were sent for catheterization and, when possible, stents or bypass surgery. Meanwhile, the other half started with medication plus diet and exercise counseling. Doctors saved procedures for anyone whose symptoms did not improve.

Over a median follow-up of nine years, the team recorded 1,071 deaths. Even so, the gap between the two groups never grew into a meaningful survival advantage. By the researchers’ own math, the invasive approach added an estimated 14 days of life over 11 years.

Fewer heart deaths, but more deaths from other causes

Here is where the story gets more interesting. Heart-related deaths ran slightly lower in the procedure group, at 15.8 percent versus 17.1 percent. However, deaths from other causes, such as cancer and infection, ran slightly higher, at 9.1 percent versus 8.1 percent.

The authors also pointed to earlier trial data showing more cancer deaths in the invasive group. In addition, they found an association between cancer deaths and the number of tests and procedures involving radiation. In our view, every patient deserves to hear about that trade-off before agreeing to a “routine” procedure.

Why we believe this study should change the conversation

Too many people walk into a heart procedure believing the stent will add years to their life. For stable patients like those in this trial, the evidence now says otherwise. Earlier NaturalHealth365 coverage showed how strongly daily eating habits shape heart attack risk, and this new study adds weight to the same message.

To be fair, the procedures did bring real benefits. Patients with chest pain who had early procedures got more relief and a better quality of life for at least the first few years. Also, stents and bypass surgery remain lifesaving during an actual heart attack, and nothing in this study changes that fact.

So, if you have been told you have stable heart disease, ask your doctor plain questions. What is the goal of the procedure, and will the procedure relieve symptoms or help you live longer? Never stop a medication or skip care on your own, but do work with a doctor who respects your right to weigh the evidence.

Natural ways to protect a stable heart

Both groups in the trial received diet and exercise counseling along with their medications. That point deserves attention, because daily habits form the foundation of heart protection, no matter which path a patient chooses. Here are practical steps worth talking over with your doctor:

  • Build meals around vegetables, fruit, nuts, beans, olive oil, and wild-caught fish. Choose organic when you can to avoid unwanted chemicals.
  • Cut back on ultra-processed snacks, sugary drinks, and fried fast food, which fuel inflammation inside the arteries.
  • Get enough magnesium, potassium, and omega-3 fats, nutrients that support a steady heart rhythm and healthy blood vessels.
  • Move your body every day, even with a simple walk after meals.
  • Protect your sleep and find healthy ways to manage stress, since both affect blood pressure.

A hopeful message for heart patients

The message from this study is empowering. For people with stable heart disease, a procedure is not the only path to a long life. In fact, medication if needed, combined with smart daily habits, gave patients nearly the same survival over more than a decade.

Most of all, you have more time and more choices than you may have been told. Use that time to ask questions, gather the facts, and build the daily habits that keep your heart strong for years to come.

To learn how to strengthen your heart and arteries with proven natural strategies, from nutrition to stress relief, explore the insights shared by leading doctors in our program. Order the Cardiovascular Docu-Class today.

Sources for this article include:

JAMAnetwork.com
NYULangone.org

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted